I Tried 7 Subway Sandwiches — Here’s the One I’ll Keep Ordering
Looking for the best Subway sandwich but unsure what to try? You’re not alone. With so many options on the menu, choosing the right Subway order can feel overwhelming. That’s why I tested 7 of the most popular Subway sandwiches—to help you figure out what’s truly worth your money.
How I Chose the Sandwiches
I selected these subs based on customer favorites, online reviews, and menu popularity. I kept them close to their original recipes and avoided major customizations, focusing instead on how they taste straight from the menu. The result? A clear ranking of the best Subway sandwich ideas to try this year.
7. Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
This sub has a loyal fanbase, but it was too sweet for me. The teriyaki sauce overpowered everything—even with banana peppers for acidity. While some love it for its sweet-and-savory blend, it didn’t work for my taste buds. If you’re trying it, add something spicy or pickled to balance it out.
6. The Mexicali
This one sounded exciting—spicy chicken, creamy guacamole, and bold flavors. But in reality, it fell flat. The guac was bland, and the overall taste was underwhelming. It’s one of those popular Subway sandwiches that needs serious customization to shine. Add jalapeños, skip the guac, and try it on multigrain bread for a better experience.
5. Veggie Delite
Surprisingly refreshing. This sub is a win when the veggies are fresh—and they were. On multigrain bread with provolone, spinach, tomatoes, and a dash of oil and vinegar, this became one of my top Subway sandwich ideas for a lighter, vegetarian-friendly option.
4. Cold Cut Combo
Simple and nostalgic. This sub features ham, salami, and bologna (all turkey-based), stacked on soft Italian bread. It’s salty, satisfying, and feels like a classic. Not the healthiest, but if you’re craving a traditional deli vibe, it’s a good Subway order to consider.
3. Meatball Marinara
Messy but delicious. The Meatball Marinara combines comfort food with a sub roll. With some green peppers and banana peppers for contrast, it reminded me of a pizza-meets-meatball-sandwich hybrid. No wonder it’s one of the most popular Subway sandwiches worldwide.
2. Oven-Roasted Turkey
A longtime favorite for a reason. It’s lean, tasty, and endlessly customizable. I chose multigrain bread, fresh veggies, and mustard, and it hit the spot. Whether you’re in the US or searching for the best Subway sandwich in India, this one is always a reliable pick.
1. Chicken & Bacon Ranch Melt – The Best Subway Sandwich
This sub truly wowed me. The seasoned chicken, smoky bacon, and creamy Peppercorn Ranch dressing came together perfectly. It’s hearty, flavorful, and worth every bite. If you’re looking for the best Subway order that delivers on taste and satisfaction, this is it.
Pro Tips for Creating the Best Subway Combos
Want to make your next Subway order even better? Use these proven tips:
- Go with the multigrain bread
While Italian bread is tempting, multigrain is heartier and holds up better with sauces and toppings.
- Add more veggies
Subway has one of the best selections of fresh veggies in the fast food world—don’t skimp! Load up on cucumbers, spinach, banana peppers, and jalapeños for extra crunch and nutrition.
- Go light on sauces
Too much sauce can ruin the texture and overpower flavors. Ask for a light amount to keep your sub balanced.
- Keep it spicy and pickle-y
A pop of acidity elevates any sandwich. Add vinegar, pickles, banana peppers, or pickled jalapeños for brightness and bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the best Subway sandwich for beginners?
Try the Oven-Roasted Turkey. It’s light, customizable, and works well with any combo of fresh veggies and sauces.
2. Which Subway sandwich is the most popular in 2025?
The Chicken & Bacon Ranch Melt continues to be a top choice among fans thanks to its rich flavor and hearty ingredients.
3. What’s a good Subway order for something healthy?
Go for the Veggie Delite or Oven-Roasted Turkey with multigrain bread, fresh veggies, and light sauce for a nutritious sub.
Conclusion:
When it comes to finding the best Subway sandwich, it’s all about balance—flavor, texture, and freshness. The Chicken & Bacon Ranch Melt stood out as the most satisfying, while the Oven-Roasted Turkey remains a healthy, classic favorite. Whether you’re exploring new Subway sandwich ideas or just want a quick meal, these tested picks won’t disappoint.
